Technically not a win, but they always treat it like one.
We'll start with this: we don't hate this dress.
From a design perspective, our criticisms are that the slit is too high.
Which, combined with the back, cheapened and tackified what could have been a classic gown.
And by "classic" we mean "DONE." A LOT. For like 40 years.
The praise this very standard garment received from the judges was absurd and embarrassing for all involved.
If you have any understanding of how the format of the show works, then you figured out a long time ago that Michael Costello was making it to the finals, come hell or high water. We're not at all surprised he made it and we can't even say we're disappointed.
We don't even think this was an auf'able dress. 
We just think the judges made fools of themselves trying to justify a decision that was made long before this challenge. We understand why the Duchess loved it so much. This IS a Michael Kors dress. And we get why Heidi liked it: she'd wear it in a second. But Nina, honey. You really had us shaking our heads sadly. "This was a phenomenally beautiful dress." Really, Nina? "Phenomenally beautiful?"
And, really? No one's going to point out the lack of imagination here? He had all of New York from which to draw inspiration for his dress. He chose a big statue of a lady in a dress.Just say it: "Even though this dress is nothing to write home about, Michael's no better or worse than a lot of these designers and he drives some of them nuts, so he gets to go to the finals." Is that so hard, judges? Someday we're going to produce a post-modern reality show where judges openly admit things like that. "I'm sorry, but you're going to have to leave because you have bad teeth and you're a little chunky." Or, "CONGRATULATIONS! YOU WON BECAUSE YOU'RE THE WHITE FINALIST!" Or "I'm not here to make friends. I'm here to make money."
We have no problem with MC going to the finals. Really, we don't. We don't even care that he didn't know what the fabric was. And we don't hate this dress. But it never should've received more than a "Good enough. You can go." from the judges. The gymnastics they went through to praise this as if it were some breathtakingly beautiful design was, frankly, pretty silly.Tim Gunn's Workroom:
Extended Judging:
[Screencaps: projectrungay.blogspot.com - Video Credit: myLifetime.com - Photo Credit: Barbara Nitke/myLifetime.com]
Post a Comment
No comments:
Post a Comment